A view on Fishing,Community and Life on the NW coast of Scotland

Three articles in the WHFP this week caught the eye and go to the very crux of the current debate on the survival of rural communities. The first being the West Harris Trust erecting a 5 kilowatt turbine to supply their school with electricity and excess to the grid. This is action on the ground taken with the hope that they not only can save their school but turn round the decline of the school roll. They are down to 6. The Trust have a target of increasing their population by 50% partly by providing affordable housing and the retention of the school is an integral part of this laudable ambition. We then move on to Scalpay, Harris where they are discussing whether to go ahead with a community buyout. This has come out of the blue and they have not suffered from a bad landlord, but they have lived through a generation of decline, both economically and socially. I found some of the stats staggering like the absence of pre school children, primary school already closed. This is on an island which had a population of 600 post WWII declining to approximately 300 now. Fishing industry devastated and the bridge built to the “mainland” of Harris along with increased education and communication opportunities seem to have all contributed to this decline. A further list too long to repeat is quite startling but also the comments from a resident, Donald Macdonald, who stated that if people had not come into the island to live the situation would be even worse. One of the possibilities is they go into partnership with the North Harris Trust which has a completely different set of figures from Scalpay since 2003 when they took over the community. The article finishes on a positive note saying that the possible buy-out is giving a boost to people to start doing things for themselves. They did in the past but have suffered from a generational “brain drain” which has diminished this in recent times. The third story that caught the eye was the future funding of the Comhairle nan Eilean Sar, The Western Isles Council, which is facing larger than average spending cuts as they are based on population figures. They are expecting a cut of 6% over two years but at the same time are experiencing larger costs because of an ageing profile in the community. Although it was a party political article the facts remained the same and , to be honest I was less interested in who was to blame than the fact that it was taking place.In the same vein I saw a fb post urging people to buy local,from the neighbour who makes jewellery or crafts,local food from the croft or veg from some one’s plot, home baking and not to send the dosh outside the community to some faceless multi national that only exists to make more money from you than the last time they did. Money kept circulating locally is worth far more than that which is earned and disappears into anonymous coffers. More and more people are getting interested in looking after their own, not at the expense of any one else but alongside each other.

It was with this in mind as I headed of to work at the Inn, expecting a routine that is to say quiet evening. Quick look round the bar and the bookings for the evening dispelled that notion. It still never ceases to amaze me about this place. At one stage we had 14 customers waiting for seats, admittedly almost every one wanted to eat in the bar and not the small dinning room. But still, a thursday evening in November with very inclement weather outside….. The Hill was almost impassable and we had to advise the family heading back to Onich to go back round the coast as the Hill was treacherous. With everyone fed and watered I got into a discussion about what is happening here and the future of the community. Lots of little snippets of gossip to keep the conversation going but the theme was the same and I mentioned some of the above and the way some people misrepresent what you say and mean. The Applecross population IS in decline,IS getting older,school roll IS in decline,PO hours ARE getting less,services ARE getting harder to maintain, far less improve, and me saying that we need 100 more people living here to keep this community viable in often met with 50 shades of horror, what would they do? where would they live? and the slightly dodgy view of would they be undesirable? whatever that means. I look around Applecross and see people not “incomers” just people who are prepared to live here and take part in this community. After all I suspect that if we went back far enough everyone “came in”, it is just not an issue. The issue is we need more and all that would do is to sustain numbers not create the implied imbalance that people use in their arguments against this as an aim. This does appear very negative but there is no point in “ochoning”,saying it’s not the way it used to be and putting our heads in the sand. The question of what people would do is answered with the fact that there is almost 100% employment here all be it not in some people’s chosen field of work. There are many basic trades that are missing and many of the new opportunities will now become available if our broadband plans come to fruition. Watch this space. I think that is the essence of the Community Company , to create the structure that allows people to prosper in a sustainable way within the area. The trick is combining “old wisdom” and new technologies in a way that is sustainable and does little disruption to the environment. Proof reading, making ice cream, having a hen care home is a classic example of this. It also means that a house my grandfather, my dad, and I lived in is still “alive” and guys that want to live here and contribute to the community can. The only way that happened was me not selling to the highest bidder and again to me that is worth far more than a few quid. Doing that on a community level is going to be far trickier and needs a mindset change but maybe …… This has all got a bit serious so back to the beauty of living here.Yesterday while taking Dougal and family up the Glen the larch plantation was looking so bright after the rare summer we had. And a couple of weeks ago on the way home this rowan,growing almost on a rock, caught my eye in the evening sun at Ardhu.For those following the competition, Pakistan arrived last night .

Comments on: "West Highland Free Press stories and local colour" (4)

  1. Jamie McIntyre said:

    More good sense as usual, Ali.

    I have not read the WHFP article but is it not the case that Scalpay has been offered to be gifted to the community by its owner? (so it is not a ‘buyout’ in the usual sense of the word).

    Some readers might not realise this particular point from your blog post, but it deserves wider recognition, and great credit is due to the enlightened landowner. Typically communities taking over their land are faced with finding large sums of money to do so, and such moves are not always encouraged by the incumbent landowners. The offer by the owner of Scalpay is a complete contrast to this, and his motives chime with the thoughts in your posting – he has been quoted as saying:

    “I have to consider future generations, and in my mind there is no question that the way forward is for the people of this island to take it over”

    The better ‘traditional’ landowners often think of themselves as having a paternal relationship with their communities. However the situation in Scalpay is really the true manifestation of such a relationship, where the ultimate expression of parental love for a child is to ‘cut the apron strings’ and let them go – or in this case, for the community to take control of the island they live on.

    • applecrosslifeattheedge said:

      Good point Jamie. The actual raising of the money to “buy out” often is a big burden to the community involved and to have a landlord like this is indeed rare in that he seems to recognise this. Scalpay, if they decide, can concentrate immediately on how to turn things round instead of worrying about huge amounts of debt to be repaid. Cheers for reading.

  2. HelloAli, just had a look at your blog following your joining the Achiltibuie Appreciation Society facebook page. Good to have you join!
    Seems like Applecross shares SO many challenges with Achiltibuie and the other wee villages of the Coigach peninsula. Coigach Community Development Company was formed to address some of our challenges of rapidly falling school roll, ageing demographic, no affordable housing, (over 50% of our housing stock are holiday houses) support for our few shops, the petrol pumps and community hall, rusting pier, the closure of our 2 biggest employers and tourist attractions, etc… The list goes on.
    There is light in our darkness though! (Apart from Coigach being a great place to live despite the challenges!)
    Backed up by a local vote of close on 70% (an 83% return of voting papers) the CCDC is about to take to full planning one single wind turbine (900kW) with the aim of generating a revenue stream for the community for the next 20 years. It could generate as much as £100,000 per year profit which would be used to assist with the housing problem, go toward setting up business units (we have none) helping to mend and improve piers …and the rest!
    We are anticipating – in fact it has already started – the usual knee-jerk anti campaign from some mountaineers and folk from outside who want to keep the beautiful place we live in ‘the same’ (apparently while the community goes gently down the tubes.)
    Hope you and members of your community will help us gain our planning permission for our community wind turbine which would be such a lifeline for our future sustainability.
    For more info and, shortly, the address to write to to show support for the community wind turbine planning application go to http://.ccdcompany.wordpress.com Thanks!

    • applecrosslifeattheedge said:

      You could be talking about Applecross and most other wee places up and down the Highlands and Islands. The only difference here is that we are not allowed a turbine but ours is a small hydro scheme. Met Peter and signed his planning petition. Do you want us to send in another support letter to planning as well? met Julia for the first time last week and although I knew Ian was there as well,never got round to speaking to him. I went to Drumossie as a director and you probably know Alison our LDO suffers me as her partner. There is a good network building up between all our communities. Long may it grow.I like the fact there is no competition but everyone wants to help every one sharing the failure as well as the success.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Tag Cloud

Wee Ginger Dug

Biting the hand of Project Fear

Beyond the Horizon

Commentary and Sustainability Policy Analysis from Dr Calum Macleod

Lenathehyena's Blog

IT'S NOT ROCKET SALAD.........in the Land o' cakes and brither Scots

Scottish Communities CAN

Scottish Communities Climate Action Network

Beyond the Bloomin' Heather

A critical discussion of the history and politics behind Scotland's most beautiful landscapes

Jean Urquhart

following dissolution of parliament this site will move to jeanurquhart.com


Re-imagining a just and green society

Derek Bateman Broadcaster1

An ongoing dialogue

derek bateman broadcaster2

My first and last ever blog (probably)

Small Scales

fisheries and ocean conservation in Atlantic Canada


e-learning, networking, and the UHI


It's got a backbeat. You can't lose it. If you wanna dance with me.

derek bateman broadcaster2

My first and last ever blog (probably)

Jessica's Nature Blog


Shawndra Miller

Giving voice to the world’s remaking

Hiking Photography

Beautiful photos of hiking and other outdoor adventures.


Just another WordPress.com site

Life at the end of the road

the trials and tribulations of an accidental crofter


A Highland GP on life the universe and anything...

%d bloggers like this: